Artificial Intelligence January 17, 2024

Establishing Boundaries: The Need for Ethical AI Surveillance Guardrails

by Barry P Chaiken, MD
Subscribe to my Dr. Barry Speaks YouTube Channel

A thought-provoking piece by The Guardian, titled”  ‘Constantly monitored’: the pushback against AI surveillance at work,” scrutinizes the escalating deployment of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in monitoring workplace activities. This article serves as a crucial reminder of the ethical and human-centric considerations that must guide the implementation of AI. This principle is profoundly relevant in the healthcare sector.

The Guardian’s article sheds light on the pervasive use of AI for employee surveillance, illustrating how AI systems in call centers, for instance, record and evaluate employee interactions, often with stringent adherence to predefined scripts. Surveillance extends to monitoring communications for sensitive words, highlighting a concerning level of intrusiveness. Workers generally do not know what monitoring tools are used, what data the tools are collecting, or how the data is used to evaluate performance.

In contrast to the United States and Canada, European nations, led by proactive labor unions, have established more robust safeguards against such invasive AI practices. Notably, Deutsche Telekom in Germany has set a precedent by banning algorithmic terminations and the use of digital monitoring data for individual worker discipline.

The article also underscores the initiatives of American labor unions, such as the Communications Workers of America, in advocating for responsible AI use. These efforts aim to ensure AI’s role as a tool for enhancing, rather than penalizing, employee performance.

However, the challenges presented by AI are significant. The potential for bias, particularly when AI systems are calibrated against a “standard” worker, raises substantial concerns about fairness and discrimination. Furthermore, the omnipresence of AI in performance monitoring can exacerbate stress and fundamentally alter the nature of work.

Balanced Approach Needed

Acknowledging the benefits of AI in improving worker performance and safety, the US Chamber of Commerce also recognizes the necessity for a balanced approach to AI deployment that addresses the technology’s potential pitfalls.

Drawing parallels to the healthcare industry, where AI’s potential to revolutionize patient care is immense, the insights from this article are particularly salient. In healthcare, we must navigate the deployment of AI with an unwavering commitment to ethical standards and human-centric values. This includes maintaining patient confidentiality, ensuring equitable access to care, and rigorously eliminating biases in AI algorithms.

The article from The Guardian is compelling evidence of the need for stringent guardrails around AI in healthcare. As we embrace the transformative power of AI in improving patient outcomes and safety, it is imperative to establish frameworks that ensure AI’s alignment with ethical principles and its role as a benefactor in healthcare. Only by setting these guardrails can we harness the full potential of AI in healthcare, ensuring it acts as a force for good, enhancing patient care while upholding the highest ethical standards.

In healthcare, as in other sectors, the journey with AI must be navigated cautiously, ensuring that technology serves humanity, not vice versa.

Source ‘Constantly monitored’: the pushback against AI surveillance work, The Guardian, January 7, 2024

I look forward to your thoughts, so please submit your comments in this post and subscribe to my weekly newsletter, “What’s Your Take?” on

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.